Why is it important for managers to recognize and deal with the Impostor Phenomenon?The Impostor Phenomenon or Syndrome is the feeling that one’s success is due to unrelated factors, rather than one’s competence and qualifications. This impacts the performance of mainly high potential individuals. According to Professors Helena Gonzalez-Gomez (NEOMA Business School), and Sarah Hudson (Rennes School of Business), there are ways to understand, manage and unleash the […]
The Impostor Phenomenon or Syndrome is the feeling that one’s success is due to unrelated factors, rather than one’s competence and qualifications. This impacts the performance of mainly high potential individuals. According to Professors Helena Gonzalez-Gomez (NEOMA Business School), and Sarah Hudson (Rennes School of Business), there are ways to understand, manage and unleash the potential of employees who feel like impostors.
3 reasons for managers to help Impostor Syndrome victims
High potential individuals
It appears that in many cases, the Impostor Syndrome affects high potential employees, who are precious for businesses.
Studies done on the subject have found that, paradoxically, it is particularly prominent in individuals with outstanding professional and academic accomplishments, and also that it is accentuated in women.
Suffering from Impostor Phenomenon may generate higher levels of stress and lowered job satisfaction. This can lead the employee to find a job elsewhere.
Commitment and performance.
Because the Impostor Syndrome is linked to a fear of being exposed as a fraud, of not deserving to be there, it can influence employee commitment and creativity, and thus performance. Importantly, performance is not affected due to lack of skills or capacity, but because of this continuous fear. This may inhibit employees with the IP to proactively work on projects and to voice new ideas.
3 keys to cope with Impostor Syndrome
The Impostor Syndrome may arise for a variety of reasons. But one is really important to understand for the manager: when someone is not confident about their worthiness, more pressure for high performance may accentuate this feeling.
This is why in a rather supportive and welcoming environment, the person suffering from the impostor syndrome may more easily cope with those feelings and start to perform at the best of their capacities.
Managerial feedback that avoids direct attributions of personal failure and rather focuses on how to improve performance in a more neutral manner is likely to increase creativity in individuals with Impostor Phenomenon.
To go further:
Using four studies with different methodologies and a total of 648 employees in US and Europe, the researchers investigated the effects of IP on performance and career outcomes.
Hudson, S., & González-Gómez, H. V. (2021). Can impostors thrive at work? The impostor phenomenon’s role in work and career outcomes. Journal of Vocational Behavior. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvb.2021.103601